Google Japan Buys Dirty Pay-Per-Post Links
Google Japan seems desperate in chasing the Mighty Yahoo! (see here for example). They are now using a tainted and controversial social media optimization method called pay-per-post, provided by CyberBuzz.
Recently, Google Japan announced a top-page redesign on their official blog, in which they added a "Google Kyuujyoushou Waado (Hot Keywords)" feature. This addition displays the 5 most searched-for keywords in the previous 24 hours. Google Japan planned the new feature to help with their tough search-share fight against nemesis Yahoo! Japan.
In the screenshot above, just below the search box section, 5 keywords are listed with links to their respective Google searches.
At the same time, there are a number of blog entries on Google's blog widget (called "blog parts" in Japanese) reviewing this "Hot Keywords" feature, all of them strangely resembling each other.
When you search for "Google Hot Keywords Ranking" + "Blog Widget" + "CyberBuzz" in Japanese on Google Blog Search, you will see over 30 posts by bloggers writing about this new service, saying things like "I'm a part of the CyberBuzz campaign" or "You can earn some money by writing interesting stories provided by CyberBuzz". (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 4)
So Google Blog Search, which has been spammed for so long, is now spamming itself in Japan.
I have translated part of a random entry as an example:
The Google Hot Keywords blog widget [link to Google's page] can show you what is in fashion now, and what other people are interested in.
It's appealing that you can view buzzwords from the previous day or the previous week. I am sometimes surprised to see that such words are so popular! Personally, I like the "fortune-teller" feature from the previous week's ranking. When I click on a keyword, I am quickly taken to Google's result page and so I enjoy the feature.
I might not have noticed them by myself, but now I understand that these things are what people care about.
I am participating in CyberBuzz's campaign.
CyberBuzz is one of the biggest pay-per-post agencies in Japan and are known for their high payouts. (Some blog posts fetch $100 for a single entry.)
So they are now link-building using monetary incentives to try to crook their own search results in a malicious way. I think this is a waste of money and only tarnishes their reputation for fairness.
Google Japan also does business with notorious news-clipping site Gigazine, and has been running a few ad campaigns which include special customized banners. There are many article-like advertisements on the site.
These articles, which look almost the same as regular ones, have "ad" tags ("広告" in Japanese) at bottom, which are very subtle, and will no doubt not be noticed by many readers. You can see for yourself by clicking the screenshot below, and reading the (poor) explanation at the bottom of the article that the entry is in fact an advertisement.
[Update 2009.02.10] Google Japan Apologizes For Inappropriate Pay Per Post Use
via Netafull
(Proofread by Sean O'Hagan)
[Update 2012-01-05] US Google did the same mistake three years later when Matt Cutts penalized Google Japan.
-
http://blog.pasonatech.co.jp/mitani/9741.html 世界を巡るFool on the web | あすなろBLOG
-
http://www.ilbloggatore.com/2009/02/11/google-compra-link-in-giappone/ Il Bloggatore – Le notizie sull’informatica, direttamente dal mondo dei blog!
-
http://viciadonogoogle.blogspot.com/2009/02/google-japao-viola-as-proprias-regras.html Viciado no Google – Tudo sobre o melhor buscador!
-
http://blogoscoped.com/archive/2009-02-10-n43.html Google’s Blogs ‘n More
-
http://clip.mitaimon.com みたいもん!クリッパー
-
http://ameblo.jp/wackyhope/entry-10206224254.html Beauty Science, Beauty Marketing, and Beauty Communication. -美容・化粧の科学とマーケティングと。
-
http://feedproxy.google.com/~r/Techcrunch/~3/X07rzsms_EY/ Unusual Fellow
-
http://www.mediologic.com/weblog/archives/001773.html mediologic.com/weblog
-
http://www.websonic.nl/nieuws/022009/google_bestraft_google_japan.php WebSonic.nl :: Webtools – PC Tips en Trucs – Tutorials
-
http://feeds.adseok.com/~r/AdseokOptimizacionEnBuscadores/~3/a8AanFggfEI/ Posicionamiento en buscadores con Adseok SEO
-
http://magiczne.seoisem.pl/2009/02/12/google-kupuje-linki-a-potem-przeprasza-i-samo-sie-karze/ Magiczne SEOiSEM ⊷
-
http://connect.icrossing.co.uk/google-japan-penalised-payperpost_1608 Connect: Digital Marketing Blog – Search Marketing – iCrossing UK
-
http://macmagazine.com.br/blog/2009/02/12/google-penaliza-pagerank-do-google-do-japao-por-comprar-links-em-blogs/ BLOG.MACMAGAZINE
-
http://www.nowhereelse.fr/google-japon-pagerank-16058/ GEEK WEBZINE de l’actu GEEK pour les GEEKS
-
http://www.motoricerca.net/2009/02/12/google-penalizza-se-stesso/ Motoricerca: notizie sui motori di ricerca, search engine marketing, ottimizzazione dei siti web
-
http://blogs.itmedia.co.jp/niikura 新倉茂彦の情報セキュリティAtoZ : ITmedia オルタナティブ・ブログ
-
http://blog.tokuriki.com/2009/02/google_payperpost.html tokuriki.com:ネットコミュニケーションの視点
-
http://www.blogobo.com/google/pay-per-post-google-uses-every-trick-to-beat-yahoo-in-japan/ BLOGOBO
-
http://www.iyahooi.com/entry/2009/02/payperpostgoogle.html i yahoo i.com:blog
-
http://megustaelturismo.es/blog/2009/02/13/google-se-penaliza-a-si-mismo/ megustaelturismo
-
http://www.groovecommerce.com/ecommerce-blog/search-engine-marketing/google-google-slaps-google-japan/ Lead Gen and eCommerce Website Design, Development, and Marketing | Groove Commerce
-
http://www.alwinclores.com/2009/02/google-penalizes-itself/ SEO Consultant Philippines | SEO Services | SEO Consultant | SEM Consultant | SEO Consultancy | SEO Analyst | SEO Expert | SEO Specialist | Search Engine Optimization | Search Engine Marketing | Alwin Clores
-
http://www.anirbanroy.info/google/google-japan-got-penalized-by-google/ I Am Blogging
-
http://nomano.shiwaza.com/tnoma/blog/archives/006829.html [の] のまのしわざ
-
http://www.webseo.es/google-penaliza-a-google-japon/ Pagerank SEO – Tu sitio sobre SEO
-
http://sejapan.net/2009/02/google-cyberbuzz-google-trends-trouble-summary.html 電脳技術者覚書
-
http://socweb.blog80.fc2.com/blog-entry-363.html social web rambling
-
http://www.riverho.com/matt-cutt-apologized-for-googlecojp-paid-for-writers/ Digital Marketer in China
-
http://saturnattacks.com/2009/03/16/la-doble-moral-de-google/ Saturn Attacks
-
http://www.jroller.com/hatano/entry/sony_s_itune_library_buster Japanese on Java
-
http://mydesign.com.ar/blog/2009/04/15/google-penaliza-a-google-japon/ MyDesign – Blog de Diseño Web
-
http://www.adseok.com Posicionamiento en buscadores con Adseok SEO
-
http://pagerank-seo.com.ar Pagerank SEO – Tu sitio sobre SEO
-
http://www.techcrunch.com/2009/02/09/pay-per-post-google-uses-every-trick-to-beat-yahoo-in-japan/ Pay Per Post: Google Uses Every Trick To Beat Yahoo In Japan
-
http://insidewebmaster.com/2009/02/google-buying-reviews-through-cyberbuzz/ insideWebmaster
-
http://hachimitu.jp/blog/archives/2009/02/09224412.html 急上昇ワードのサイバーバスはGoogleじゃなくて、ブログデコの広告では? – hachimitu blog
-
http://jp.techcrunch.com/archives/20090209pay-per-post-google-uses-every-trick-to-beat-yahoo-in-japan/ Yahooからの市場奪取に向けて手段を選ばぬGoogle、PayPerPostキャンペーンを採用
-
http://asiajin.com/blog/2009/02/10/google-japan-apologizes-for-inappropriate-pay-per-post-use/ Google Japan Apologizes For Inappropriate Pay Per Post Use | Asiajin
-
http://redpen.jp/2009/02/10_18299.php グーグルの失策「ペイパーポスト問題」、非難からは何も生まれない | マーケティング、ネット広告、EC情報を日々お届けするRedPen
-
http://www.yugatech.com/blog/blogosphere/google-caught-paid-post-in-japan/ Google caught doing paid post in Japan | YugaTech | Philippines, Technology News & Reviews
-
http://googlediscovery.com/2009/02/10/google-japao-e-acusado-de-fazer-posts-pagos/ Google Japão é acusado de fazer posts pagos – Google Discovery
-
http://d.hatena.ne.jp/inamenai/20090211/p1 GIGAZINEε・ャ・䤹・reasemonkey・ラネ – inamenaiホニ・ュ
-
http://www.pamil-visions.net/google-gets-dirty/ Google Buys Links in Sponsored Reviews
-
http://seoblackhat.com/2009/02/10/the-following-pay-per-post-was-paid-for-by-google/ The Following Pay Per Post Was Paid for by Google
-
http://www.gexiaofei.com/20090211535.html Pay Per Post其实不错的 | 葛小飞
-
http://slashdot.jp/it/article.pl?sid=09/02/11/1149213 グーグル日本法人「急上昇ワード」の汚い宣伝手法で自滅 – スラッシュドット・ジャパン
-
http://www3.atword.jp/gnome/2009/02/11/google-apologize-their-pay-par-post-itself/ UnderForge of Lack » Blog Archive » Google apologize their pay-par-post itself
-
http://www.blogoergosum.com/4948-google-japan-est-desespere-et-sen-excuse Google Japan est desespéré et s’en excuse !
-
http://pocitace.sme.sk/c/4304507/japonsky-google-platil-blogerom-aby-klamali.html Japonsk Google platil blog駻om, aby klamali | Spr疱y | pocitace.sme.sk
-
http://www.ben-ari.name/archives/1646 גוגל יפן שילמה לבלוגרים, נענשה על ידי גוגל העולמית | מחפש ברשת
-
http://www.sistrix.de/news/850-google.co.jp-nach-linkkauf-nur-noch-mit-pagerank-5.html Google.co.jp nach Linkkauf nur noch mit PageRank 5 – SISTRIX Suchmaschinen- & SEO-Blog
-
http://www.pagetrafficblog.com/google-penalizes-google-japan/5952/ Google Penalizes Google Japan! » PageTraffic SEO Blog
-
http://www.netzideen-gmbh.de/blog/google-bestraft-sich-selbst/ Google kauft Links und bestraft sich selbst. Ein bitterer Beigeschmack bleibt trotzdem. | Beitrag | netzideen Unternehmensblog
-
http://www.relevansanalys.se/google-ertappad-med-kopta-lankar-for-att-vinna-over-yahoo/ Google ertappad med köpta länkar för att vinna över Yahoo | Relevansanalys sökmotoroptimering & domäner
-
http://jurnalsem.com/bila-google-di-tempat-baru/ Bila Google Di Tempat Baru… | JurnalSEM
-
http://www.bestnotizie.com/4840/google-penalizza-anche-se-stesso/ » Google penalizza anche se stesso
-
http://www.onlinerambo.com/%d7%92%d7%95%d7%92%d7%9c-%d7%a7%d7%95%d7%a0%d7%94-%d7%a4%d7%95%d7%a1%d7%98%d7%99%d7%9d-%d7%91%d7%91%d7%9c%d7%95%d7%92%d7%99%d7%9d-%d7%95%d7%9e%d7%aa%d7%a0%d7%a6%d7%9c%d7%aa/ פרסום גרילה באינטרנט – ינאי הנגבי » Blog Archive » גוגל קונה פוסטים בבלוגים ומתנצלת
-
http://despuesdegoogle.com/2009/02/12/google-se-autorebaja-su-pagerank-en-japon/ despuesdegoogle » Blog Archive » Google se autorebaja su PageRank en Japón
-
http://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-japan-penalized-by-google-for-paid-links/8590/ Google Japan Penalized by Google for Paid Links
-
http://wahlqvist.co.uk/google-says-no-no-to-google/ Google says no no, to Google | Wahlqvist
-
http://www.adamcrawford.co.uk/google-ban-themselves-again/ Google ban themselves again at Adam Crawford
-
http://www.research-tr.com/googlein-kestigi-parmak-acimaz/ Google’ın Kestiği Parmak Acımaz | Re*Search
-
http://www.kadekbagus.com/2009/02/15/google-jepang-kena-penalti-dari-google/ Google jepang kena penalti dari Google? | Kadek Bagus Official Site
-
http://www.cheethai.com/tech-news/google-penalized-google-japan-the-end-of-payperpost Your Digital Life Style | Tech News | Google Penalized Google Japan. The end of PayPerPost ?
-
http://www.seoshootout.com/2009/02/google-japan-falls-on-its-links-sword/ Google Japan Falls on Its (Links) Sword | SEO ShootOut
-
http://www.moteurzine.com/2009/02/16/googlecojp-spam-linking-yahoocojp/ Google sanctionne Google.co.jp page rank black hat spam linking Yahoo
-
http://www.accuracast.com/search-daily-news/seo-7471/google-japan-to-google-were-sorry/ Google Japan to Google, “We’re Sorry” | AccuraCast Search Daily News
-
http://www.chinamyhosting.com/seoblog/2009/02/17/google-japan-paid-links/ Google挥刀自宫给站长看 – 搜索引擎优化SEO每天一贴
-
http://videos.webpronews.com/2009/02/16/wpn-exclusive-matt-cutts-apologizes-on-behalf-of-googles-penalty-against-google-japan/ Video: Matt Cutts Apologizes on Behalf of Google's Penalty against Google Japan
-
http://asiajin.com/blog/2009/02/18/apologies-to-google-cyberbuzz-is-not-pay-per-post-so-they-say/ Apologies to Google: CyberBuzz Is Not Pay-Per-Post (so they say) | Asiajin
-
http://www.giolicious.com/matt-cutts-expressed-regret-for-googles-penalty-towards-google-japan.html Matt Cutts Expressed Regret for Google’s Penalty towards Google Japan at giolicious.com
-
http://www.massmedia.comoj.com/?p=729 Google Penalizes Itself | Mass Media News-Web News
-
http://believedesign.net/seo/google-guilty-of-buying-paid-links Google guilty of buying paid links… | SEO | Believe Design – anything is possible…
-
http://www.onlinemarketingperformance.com/google-outs-self-for-pay-per-post-scheming/ Google Japan and pay-per-post link-building
-
http://www.seomarketing.co.il/2009/02/is-google-believe-in-web-marketing/ האם גוגל לא מאמינה בשיווק באינטרנט? | קידום אתרים באינטרנט | קידום אתרים בגוגל | שיווק באינטרנט
-
http://asiajin.com/blog/2009/03/03/google-japan-top-menu-localization/ Google Japan, Top Menu Localization | Asiajin
-
http://asiajin.com/blog/2009/03/31/google-japan-removes-hot-keywords-from-its-top/ Google Japan Removes Hot Keywords From Its Top | Asiajin
-
http://blog.fkoji.com/2009/02092138.html Googleがペイ・パー・ポストに手を出した – F.Ko-Jiの「一秒後は未来」
-
http://www.webpronews.com/topnews/2009/02/16/google-penalizes-itself Google Penalizes Itself | WebProNews
-
http://blackhat.gr/blackhat-seo/blackhat-seo Blackhat SEO | BlackHat.gr
-
http://www.techwankers.com/2010/01/28/dear-wanksta-how-evil-is-google/ Dear wanksta – How evil is Google? | Tech Wankers
-
http://asiajin.com/blog/2010/04/13/google-abolishes-japan-local-president-koichiro-tsujino-resigns-this-month/ Asiajin » Google Abolishes Japan Local President. Koichiro Tsujino Resigns This Month







